Comments on: Trevor Scott at Defensive End Still Not Enough to Stop Run http://justblogbaby.com/2010/09/09/trevor-scott-at-defensive-end-still-not-enough-to-stop-run/ An Oakland Raiders Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and more. Fri, 03 May 2013 16:12:24 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.4.1 By: Chris Shellcroft http://justblogbaby.com/2010/09/09/trevor-scott-at-defensive-end-still-not-enough-to-stop-run/comment-page-1/#comment-3157 Chris Shellcroft Fri, 10 Sep 2010 16:33:52 +0000 http://justblogbaby.com/?p=4049#comment-3157 Panther, We both agree that neither Shaughnessy nor Scott are the answer as far as stopping the run goes. My point is that Scott is more disciplined in his assingments than Shaughnessy. Neither is very strong and both rely heavily on their athletic ability. Scott, to me, has better one-on-one skills than Shaughnessy. Plus, you said it yourself. Shaughnessy was nowhere to be found this preseason. He had a real chance to cement his spot with the first team and didn't take advantage. I'm not saying Scott is better, he's just a better option. But in all honestly, the difference is like a Big Mac compared to a Whopper. All depends on your taste but neither is an In-N-Out burger anyway. Panther,

We both agree that neither Shaughnessy nor Scott are the answer as far as stopping the run goes. My point is that Scott is more disciplined in his assingments than Shaughnessy. Neither is very strong and both rely heavily on their athletic ability. Scott, to me, has better one-on-one skills than Shaughnessy.

Plus, you said it yourself. Shaughnessy was nowhere to be found this preseason. He had a real chance to cement his spot with the first team and didn’t take advantage.

I’m not saying Scott is better, he’s just a better option. But in all honestly, the difference is like a Big Mac compared to a Whopper. All depends on your taste but neither is an In-N-Out burger anyway.

]]> By: Black Panther http://justblogbaby.com/2010/09/09/trevor-scott-at-defensive-end-still-not-enough-to-stop-run/comment-page-1/#comment-3156 Black Panther Fri, 10 Sep 2010 07:35:44 +0000 http://justblogbaby.com/?p=4049#comment-3156 Why, I agree that Scott is weak against the run, but you floored me by saying he is an upgrade over Shaughnessy. Did you watch the games last year? Shaughnessy is MUCH better against the run. IMO, he lost his starter spot because he may bad decisions against the run during the preseason and got caught crashing inside at times, but from a physical standpoint he can do it and he's proven it in games. Scott on the other can has proven he can't stop the run at two different positions. I honestly don't know how you can call Scott an upgrade against the run. Why, I agree that Scott is weak against the run, but you floored me by saying he is an upgrade over Shaughnessy. Did you watch the games last year? Shaughnessy is MUCH better against the run. IMO, he lost his starter spot because he may bad decisions against the run during the preseason and got caught crashing inside at times, but from a physical standpoint he can do it and he’s proven it in games. Scott on the other can has proven he can’t stop the run at two different positions. I honestly don’t know how you can call Scott an upgrade against the run.

]]>