The Raiders only acquire average quarterbacks
Since the JaMarcus Russell fiasco in 2007, the team has obviously had a hard time dipping back into the draft. As a result, they've almost exclusively signed free agents or traded for quarterbacks.
And their track record is hideous.
Here are those acquisitions:
Player | Year | Acquired via |
---|---|---|
Daunte Culpepper | 2007 | Free Agency |
Josh McCown | 2007 | Trade (4th rounder) |
Bruce Gradkowski | 2009 | Waiver Claim |
Charlie Frye | 2009 | Free Agency |
JP Losman | 2009 | Free Agency |
Jason Campbell | 2010 | Trade (4th rounder) |
Kyle Boller | 2011 | Free Agency |
Carson Palmer | 2011 | Trade (1st and 2nd rounder) |
Terrelle Pryor | 2012 | Supplemental Draft |
Matt Leinart | 2012 | Free Agency |
Matt McGloin | 2013 | Undrafted Free Agent |
Matt Flynn | 2013 | Trade (5th rounder) |
Matt Schaub | 2014 | Trade (6th rounder) |
EJ Manuel | 2017 | Free Agency |
AJ McCarron | 2018 | Trade (5th rounder) |
Mike Glennon | 2019 | Free Agency |
Marcus Mariota | 2020 | Free Agency |
Nathan Peterman | 2020 | Free Agency |
Jarrett Stidham | 2022 | Free Agency |
Jimmy Garoppolo | 2023 | Free Agency |
Brian Hoyer | 2023 | Free Agency |
Gardner Minshew | 2024 | Free Agency |
Whew. What a list of All-Stars.
The team has traded away more picks for quarterbacks (7) than they have used picks on quarterbacks (4).
I know your quarterback room can't always be filled exclusively with players you've drafted, and sometimes there are viable options through trade, free agency, or even the waiver wire.
But when you've had no real success in so many years, and you continue to only acquire quarterbacks from outside of the draft, you have to switch it up. You cannot keep thinking you are a band-aid quarterback away from the promised land.
The Raiders have had 27 different players take snaps under center since 2007, and only five of them were drafted by the franchise.
When you're averaging almost two quarterbacks per season, something is already wrong. But the ratio of acquired vs. drafted talent should never be over 5:1.
Honestly, this list is a flat-out embarrassment and an indictment of all who have been involved with the organization for the last two decades.
The team has won 111 games since 2007, and 75 of them have been by drafted players (63 by Derek Carr, 7 by JaMarcus Russell, 5 by Aidan O'Connell).
This means that these 22 acquisitions have mustered 36 wins for the Silver and Black in 17 years. What a complete waste.
To make matters worse, they've had their opportunities to correct their mistakes. They just haven't capitalized.