Skip to main content

Raiders can't go back to Malcolm Koonce well this offseason if nothing changes

Las Vegas needs more.
ByLevi Dombro
Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Malcolm Koonce
Las Vegas Raiders defensive end Malcolm Koonce | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

Every offseason, the Las Vegas Raiders go hunting for a legitimate running mate for Maxx Crosby. And every offseason, the front office fails to find one. While John Spytek has done a good job at the helm of the Silver and Black, he, too, whiffed this past spring trying to find a Crosby complement.

Spytek's solution was to sign Kwity Paye to a three-year, $48 million deal, re-sign Malcolm Koonce to a one-year, $11 million contract, and to draft Keyron Crawford in Round 3 of the 2026 NFL Draft. That sounded like a good plan, in theory, but in practice, it has not worked out in the slightest.

The Raiders have one of the worst pass rushes in the league yet again.

Paye has an out in his contract after 2027, but that won't help the Raiders next year. Crawford should return from a season-ending Achilles injury, so he'll be part of the equation as well. But Las Vegas simply cannot go back to the Koonce well once again this offseason and hope he solves things.

Koonce is a fine player, but not worth the consecutive contracts that Spytek gave him. He's at a point where promise shouldn't buy him time. Koonce isn't playing well or consistently enough to get his deal renewed next year, so the Raiders should dive back into the DE wilderness and let him walk.

Malcolm Koonce is not currently playing well enough for Raiders to re-sign him

After Week 1, it felt like Paye was going to be the Robin to Crosby's Batman. When his production waned, Koonce picked up the slack and kept the Las Vegas pass rush humming. At times, he even showed flashes of his 2023 self, which started this whole love affair in the first place.

But he has been MIA ever since, and so has Paye. Koonce's snap share has dwindled with his output. When comparing the first five games of the season to the last five, it paints a glaring picture of a player who is both inconsistent and not meeting the standards of his contract, or helping out much.

Here are those numbers, courtesy of Pro Football Focus (h/t Bleacher Report's Matt Holder).

Stat

Weeks 1-5

Weeks 6-10

Sacks

3.0

0.0

Pressures

16

8

Pass-Rush Win Rate

19.4%

10.0%

Falling off a cliff like this cannot be explained entirely by a loss of playing time. When comparing these two sample sizes, Koonce played just four percent fewer snaps from Weeks 6-10 than he did in Weeks 1-5, even if he's had two really low-snap-share games recently. That is quite comparable.

He was never a great run defender, but what Koonce provided was a jolt as a pass-rusher. Now, he is not even providing that. The Raiders have re-signed him in each of the last two offseasons on a short-term basis, but if he isn't helping right now and is not locked into the long-term picture...

Why bring him back next March?

Instead, Las Vegas should invest its money in another edge rusher this offseason. Let's discuss a few options, both in the 2027 NFL Draft and on the free-agent market next spring.

Potential Malcolm Koonce replacements Las Vegas should consider

2027 NFL Draft

Las Vegas isn't likely to target an edge rusher in the early rounds next April with so many other, more pressing needs. But let's highlight a few mid-round prospects that the Raiders have watched play live already this season: LSU's Jordan Ross and Princewill Umanmielen.

Jordan Ross, LSU

Ross is a big prospect at 6-foot-5 and 254 pounds, and he has a great knack for getting after the quarterback and bringing him down. He has recorded 6.0 sacks and 36 total pressures this year, and Ross makes havoc plays as well, recording an interception and forcing a fumble.

He is explosive and has great speed off the line of scrimmage, and he is a flexible athlete with great bend around the edge. Ross can also play the run well and has the ability to line up inside, over or outside the tackle. He's fresh off a monster performance against Texas' great offensive tackles.

Princewill Umanmielen, LSU

Umanmielen is an inch smaller than Ross, but they weigh the same. Not only does he also have great athleticism and bend, but Umanmielen has power, is highly productive, and shows up in big moments. This season, he's logged 9.5 sacks and 39 pressures, in addition to 24 run stops. He does it all.

Last year, he was productive at Ole Miss as well, and his brother is currently on the Carolina Panthers after being a third-round pick in 2025, so Umanmielen has the pedigree. The Raiders cannot go wrong with either of these mid-round prospects, and they've seen them each play three times.

Also considered: Damon Wilson II, John Henry Daly, Clev Lubin, Devan Thompkins, Quincy Rhodes, Kenyatta Jackson

Free agency

Yaya Diaby, Bucs

Diaby was drafted by the Tampa Bay Buccaneers when Spytek was in their front office, so these two should already have a relationship. Diaby has just 3.0 sacks this year after recording 19.0 total sacks in his first three seasons, but he is still getting after the quarterback effectively.

His pass-rush win rate numbers are also down, but Diaby has been playing injured and has missed the last few games for Tampa Bay. But if the Bucs let him hit the market and he's healthy, this feels like a no-brainer for the Raiders to pursue.

Tuli Tuipulotu, Chargers

Chargers GM Joe Hortiz notably omitted Tuipulotu when talking about the team's young core before the deadline, and that spoke volumes. Like Diaby, he is having somewhat of a down year, logging just 3.0 sacks after tallying 26.0 in his first three seasons. But Tuipulotu is still a great player.

Not only has he totaled 33 pressures on the year with a 15.7 percent pass-rush win rate, but Tuipulotu is also solid against the run. Signing him may be expensive and would likely net Los Angeles a comp pick, but the main goal here is to solidify the pass rush, and Tuipulotu could do just that.

Also considered: Byron Young, Kayvon Thibodeaux, Uchenna Nwosu

Add us as a preferred source on Google