Just days after shipping Maxx Crosby off to the Baltimore Ravens, the Las Vegas Raiders spent $48 million on free agent defensive end Kwity Paye. The Raiders had a spending floor to reach, yes, but even at the time, this felt like an overpay. And the first 10 games of his tenure have not dispelled this.
After Week 1, that $16 million annual price tag seemed like a heist, as Paye dominated the Dolphins. He looked like the ultimate Crosby complement and a versatile defensive lineman who could help out the whole front with his ability to move around. The nine weeks since then have shown the opposite.
Paye isn't getting home at all as a pass rusher, and his run defense has been spotty. Simply put, he has come nowhere close to living up to his big contract so far. But perhaps the Raiders could adjust his role to salvage some of the sunk cost by making him more of a 3-5 tech who is a run specialist.
Kwity Paye isn't cutting it for Raiders at defensive end
There is so much value in run-stoppers, but defensive ends simply must get after the quarterback as well. In Week 1, Paye did just that, recording 2.0 sacks, two hits and three hurries while notching eight total pressures. But even in that game, Paye wasn't exactly winning pass-rush reps.
He recorded a 9.5 percent pass-rush win rate; his getting home was a product of good coverage downfield, which helped Paye sack the quarterback after multiple efforts. Unfortunately, he was exposed the very next week, as Paye had a 0.0 percent pass-rush win rate against the Chargers.
0.0.
That's right; Paye didn't win a single one of his 19 reps against Los Angeles. But that game wasn't exactly an exception, as Paye has recorded a pass-rush win rate of 0.0 in five of the team's 10 games this season. In half of the contests that he has played, Paye has not won a single pass-rush rep.
It is impossible to accurately describe just how bad that is.
Only once has Paye been in the double digits (10.0 percent pass-rush win rate in Week 7 vs. the Rams), and only three times has he even eclipsed 5.0 percent. This is a historically bad pass-rush year for Paye, as he is dead last among 63 qualifying edge rushers in win rate. By 2.4 percent.
Las Vegas knew that Paye wasn't going to be a superstar when it signed him, but it probably did not imagine him being completely ineffective while playing a 61.2 percent snap share. At this point, barring an unprecedented turnaround, Paye will never live up to his big contract.
But the Raiders can salvage some of it by adjusting his role and almost making him a defensive tackle.
Should Las Vegas bite the bullet and move Paye inside to DT?
First things first, Paye would need to gain some weight. NFL defensive tackles are about 285 pounds at the low end, and Paye is currently listed at 265 on the Raiders' official website. Given the incredible strength and nutrition programs that they have in Las Vegas, I think it could get done in an offseason.
As it turns out, Paye doesn't have the athleticism, bend or quickness to beat offensive tackles at this level, so perhaps his best bet is to line up over guards or, at the widest, on the inside shoulder of the tackle with an edge rusher on the outside of him.
Although Paye is not great against the run, he is fairly solid, and perhaps moving him inside would help shore up some of the Raiders' run-stopping issues on the interior. It's worth a shot, as Paye has been good at setting the edge this year, so he has good instincts against the ground game.
If he ever pops up on your TV screen on Sundays, it is with a good play against the run. Paye at least has the potential to help out there.
Lining him up against guards would also help erase some of the deficiencies that get exposed when Paye goes to work against offensive tackles, who are more athletic and bigger on average than guards. Paye could essentially be a 3- to 5-tech, in a similar mold to Tonka Hemingway this year.
Learning a new position is not easy, especially at his age and given all of the reps that he has banked at defensive end. But he's always sprinkled in some reps in the B gap or closer to the interior, both collegiately and in the NFL.
In college, Paye lined up in the A and B gaps with some regularity during his first three seasons, and perhaps he can dive deeper into that in Las Vegas. The experiment with him playing tons of snaps on the edge is pretty much over; give Malcolm Koonce a chance to play more, or, more so, Cian Slone.
The Raiders shouldn't need to see anything more from Paye, the defensive end/edge rusher. But if they want to at least see what kind of juice they can squeeze out of him for the rest of 2026 and in the 2027 season, then Las Vegas should try to tweak his role and salvage some of that value.
While Las Vegas has an out in Paye's deal after 2027, simply cutting him this coming offseason would bring a dead cap hit of $16.8 million next year. They have to try to make something work with him, and this is about the only thing that is worth pursuing. Him as a starting edge rusher isn't viable anymore.
